9. The Grave Truth

Complete story — includes the ending

Emma (as Sutton) confronts Ted and he comes clean about everything. He was the one who left Derek flowers, even though he insists he wasn't the killer, because he felt that Derek was too young to die despite the fact that Derek had been blackmailing him. Ted confirms that he's her birth father and that Rebecca is her birth mother. He also reveals that he was the one that Theresa ran into the other night, but was uninvolved in her disappearance as they had parted ways beforehand. Mads talks to her father about her feelings on Jordan and Rebecca. Just as he promised Emma (as Sutton), Ted goes to Dan the following morning to tell him about his encounter with Theresa before she disappeared. Dan doesn't buy Ted's account and starts getting aggressive before Alec walks in to defend Ted. He also tells Dan that he thinks Rebecca is behind both Derek's death and Theresa's disappearance. Jordan sees Rebecca locking a mysterious box into a drawer. Rebecca calls Kristin out in public for kissing her husband. Ethan gets into trouble with Dan when Dan finds out that Ethan had suspected Ted sooner and didn't tell him. Dan kicks Ethan out of the trailer. Kristin offers him a spot on their couch, making it awkward for Emma and Thayer. Ted becomes more cautious around Rebecca. Ethan tells Emma that he doesn't regret not telling Dan because he wanted to help her. They almost kiss. Emma and Sutton touch bases on Rebecca's situation, as Sutton had gotten nowhere after accusing her of everything. Kristin talks to Thayer about maybe not getting too serious about his relationship with Emma (as Sutton), since they're both still young. The group, consisting of the twins, Laurel, Ethan, Mads, and the newly recruited Jordan, seeks to bring Rebecca down. Emma reveals herself to Ted, as the twins want him to help them get the truth out of Rebecca, since Jordan and Sutton have been burning bridges with her lately. Ted then confronts Alec about splitting his girls up. When Rebecca is away, Jordan goes into her room to get her box, but a masked intruder has gotten it first and Jordan chases the person out of the house, causing Mads to be knocked over in the process. Laurel and Sutton are having a heartfelt conversation at the cabin when Sutton suddenly gets a call from Theresa's phone. The only thing she hears is someone heavily breathing. The two head to the police station, where Ethan and Dan are. They trace the phone back to the country club, where Emma and Thayer had been talking. Police cars arrive to block of the entire area as the phone is recovered around the back. The twins cannot be seen together, but they realize that someone has to be there to offer Ethan moral support during this time and Sutton accepts that Emma and Ethan are meant to be together, so Emma assumes Sutton's identity as she heads back out to the hectic scene. One of the officers turns the pool light on and they discover Theresa's lifeless body in the water.