EPISODE

1. Let the Punishment Fit the Crime

An unscrupulous ambulance-chasing lawyer gets stuck in a strange town for moving violations, and soon learns that the punishment for even petty crimes in the town comes with a gruesome result.

Description: Description source · Content or data license. Source formatting adapted for this entry.

THIS ENTRY’S STORY

Plot summary and ending

Spoilers ahead. Coverage follows the scope labeled below.

Complete story — includes the ending

Geraldine Ferrett ( Catherine O'Hara ), a shameless and unscrupulous ambulance-chasing lawyer, is arrested for having an illegal license plate in the remote town of Stueksville. She discovers that the town's court system is nightmarishly backwards, presided over by three identical judges ( Joseph Maher in a triple role) who sentence people to torture and even capital punishment for petty crimes. Her public defender, Austin Haggard ( Peter MacNicol ), tries to get each of the judges to assign Geraldine to public service, but he may have ulterior motives.

Sources and content license

Source and revision history · Adapted from Wikipedia contributors, List of Tales from the Crypt episodes. HTML formatting and reference markers removed. · Content license