9. What Did We Do?

Complete story — includes the ending

Catherine runs away after being confronted by Michaela, Caleb, and Connor about the gun. Asher's father commits suicide, leading Asher's mother to disown him. Sinclair accuses Nate of tampering with Philip's file, triggering an outburst from Nate that almost gets him fired. In retaliation, Nate files a harassment lawsuit, based on racism, against Sinclair. After Sinclair badmouths Asher's father, Asher runs her over with his car, killing her. Annalise frantically tries to help cover everything up by having Frank find Catherine and frame her for Sinclair's murder, and has Asher and Bonnie throw Sinclair's body off of the roof to make it look like the cause of death. Annalise tries desperately to get one of the Keating Four to shoot her, intending to blame it on Catherine. When none of the students are willing to shoot Annalise, she reveals to Wes that Rebecca is dead, leading Wes to shoot her in the gut instead of the leg like she planned. Wes is about to shoot Annalise again; he points the gun at her face at close range, but before he can squeeze the trigger, Annalise whispers Wes' birth name, Christophe. Shocked that Annalise knows his real name, he puts the gun down. Flashback: A 12-year-old Wes is being interviewed by a detective about his mother's suicide. It is revealed that a young Annalise and Eve Rothlo are watching his interview, with Eve saying, "Good God, Annalise, what did we do?"