Season 2

Complete listed story — includes the ending

1. Los Moscos

After showing Ben an explosion of massive destruction in a desert, Management reveals himself as Lucius Belyakov, the Russian soldier from Ben's dreams. He tells Ben to find Henry Scudder to learn the name of his enemy, the preacher from his dreams. Samson is to further act as their intermediary, and it is his first task to get rid of Lodz's body. Jonesy and Sofie are the only ones to survive the trailer fire; Samson presents Apollonia's burned body to the police, claiming that fugitive Ben was killed in the fire. Meanwhile, Scudder's trinket prompts Ben to revisit the Templar Lodge in Loving, where he learns that Scudder was once involved with chaplain Devin Kerrigan. After meeting in 1923, Kerrigan seemingly lost his mind and painted a tattooed man into a Templar mural; he is now institutionalized in Alamogordo. Brother Justin visits Norman, who after suffering a stroke is unable to speak. On his way home, Justin sees a decrepit tree that he already encountered in a vision about the Tattooed Man and the Usher. Following another vision at the foot of the tree, Justin declares, "this will be my New Canaan. [a] Here, I will build a temple." Wilfred Talbot Smith meets up with Brother Justin in Dolan's radio studio, predicting Justin will become the Prophet and the Usher as soon as he kills a man named Henry Scudder. He then hands Justin the Gospel of Matthias, a Templar book that once belonged to Scudder. Justin's "Church of the Air" radio speech reaches Varlyn Stroud in prison.

2. Alamogordo, N.M.

Ben finds Kerrigan in his room covered with drawings of the Tattooed Man, repeating a mantra talking of a crone. On his way back to the carnival, Ben drives past the desert from an earlier vision. He picks up a wandering, disoriented Sofie, accompanied by visions of the Tattooed Man. Sofie finds a new home in Lodz's trailer, but Lodz's former lover, Lila, grows suspicious of his unexplained disappearance. After receiving Kerrigan's poem and one of his drawings, Management informs Ben of the relevance of the Tattooed Man as the Usher, and that they need to find an old lady in Ingram, Texas. Varlyn Stroud, Brother Justin's "archangel made flesh", kills a prison guard and escapes, then sets out to find Henry Scudder. He visits the Hawkins Farm, then proceeds to Tipton. After killing the sheriff, he finds a 1921 letter to Rebecca Donovan from Scudder in Babylon. While Brother Justin breaks ground for his Temple of Jericho near the decrepit tree, Dolan collects evidence tying Iris to the ministry fire. Justin gets his chest and back tattooed with a tree. Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Makeup for a Series (Non-Prosthetic)".

3. Ingram, TX

Sofie abandons her job as a fortune teller and takes on manual labor, which incurs the resentment of the male rousties. Money problems, compounded by Stumpy's gambling habit, force the Dreifuss family to work harder. Ruthie sees apparitions of Lodz repeatedly. Ben learns the route to the crone from a tramp, but gets lost in a forest and is apprehended by a family of roughnecks, who torture and begin to bury him alive. However, Scudder's trinket saves him from death. Stroud arrives in Babylon and learns that Scudder was the only man to survive the 1921 mine cave-in. Larger crowds of followers arrive at the Temple of Jericho. Justin sexually abuses the new maid in the presence of Norman, who has been transferred to the Crowes' home for caretaking.

4. Old Cherry Blossom Road

The locals bring Ben to Emma "The Crone" Krohn, mother of Henry Scudder, and their and Ben's grandmother. Ben learns about the grisly fate of his relatives, and finds his father's death mask. Before Ben departs, Emma gives him a trench knife, explaining that he will need it where he is going, a place "where the dog and the wolf howl at the moon." Jonesy sympathizes with Sofie as the only female among the roustabouts, but cannot prevent Rita Sue from noticing his growing affection for Libby. Ruthie repeatedly sees Apollonia in burned clothes. After visiting the Templar Lodge in Loving, Stroud learns that a boy and a midget asked about Scudder. Dolan confronts Justin with evidence of Iris's guilt, but Justin refuses to accept his findings. The Crowes get a new maid. Awards: Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".

5. Creed, OK

The address carved on Scudder's death mask leads Ben to Evander Geddes in Creed, Oklahoma. After an unsettling experience in Geddes' workshop, Ben leaves with the knowledge that Scudder is still alive. At the carnival, Ruthie approaches Sofie about her experiences with dead people, and Sofie starts seeing apparitions of her mother. Stroud enters the fair grounds and antagonizes Jonesy about the safety of the Ferris Wheel, while Samson tries to deflect Stroud by directing him to another carnival, the Daily Brothers Show. Late at night, Sofie gives Ben a card reading, inducing visions of Scudder in a tuxedo, a man scarred beyond recognition, and a location where a dog and a wolf howl at the moon. After looking through Samson's photo album, Ben recognizes the location as Damascus, Nebraska. Dolan collects final evidence that Iris has something to hide. After a talk with her brother, Iris lets Dolan transcribe her confession about the ministry fire. Justin receives a mask of Ben by mail.

6. The Road to Damascus

On the road to Damascus, the carnival crosses paths with surviving members of the burned-down Daily Brothers Show. They suspect the former owners to have laid the fire, not knowing that Stroud instigated the crime and murdered the Dailey brothers. Felix admits his continued money problems to Rita Sue and gets into a fight with Jonesy over Libby. Lila has a strange encounter with Ruthie reminding her of Lodz. Ben and Sofie, who spent all day with each other, get intimate. After Ben drives off to pursue Stroud, the carnival heads for its next location, leaving Sofie behind. Stroud exploits the idea that "the best way to follow someone is to get ahead of them." Preparations are made for Iris's public confession, but in a mysterious twist, Dolan is deceived into a public confession for the crime, and he is arrested as the culprit. Awards: Emmy nominations for "Outstanding Cinematography for a Single-Camera Series" and "Outstanding Costumes for a Series".

7. Damascus, NE

While Sofie's absence is the topic of speculation at the carnival, Jonesy and Libby passionately consummate their mutual attraction. Ben locates Scudder's old hotel room in Damascus, where he has visions of a man acid-burning his face. Ben locates this man near the reception area and heals him, revealing Scudder. They elude Stroud and head to the carnival, where Scudder is violently coerced by Management into identifying Ben's enemy as Alexei Belyakov, Management's son. When Management attacks Scudder in rage, Ben comes to his father's aid and stabs Management repeatedly with his grandmother's trench knife. Brother Justin has visions of approaching death as somehow correlated with a Ferris wheel. An ambulance takes away another of the Crowes' maids who they claim has "a case of bad nerves." During a public radio broadcast, Brother Justin tears up a pre-approved sermon and improvises an incendiary jeremiad that indicts his superiors. Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Prosthetic Makeup for a Series, Miniseries, Movie or a Special". Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".

8. Outskirts, Damascus, NE

As Management draws his last breath, he teaches Ben the right way for the blade to enter the tree. Ben explains to Samson why he had to kill Management, that he now possesses Management's knowledge, and that he knows about Stroud's intentions and his link to the Usher. At first Samson is furious and accuses Ben of killing his friend. However, after Ruthie claims that seeing Scudder and a bald-headed man the previous night is further evidence that she sees dead people, Samson begins to understand that Ben is telling the truth. Ruthie rejects Lila's approaches about her supposed sleepwalking. The Dreifuss family faces new troubles with Libby's marriage to Jonesy, and an attempt to sort out their problems with a family dinner ends in an argument. That night, a Ferris wheel accident kills a young boy and injures his mother. When Samson sees Ben transfer the mother's life to her child, Ben gains Samson's trust and instructs the carnival to head west in search of Scudder and Stroud. At the moment of Management's death, Justin has a seizure, which Wilfred Talbot Smith explains as Justin's enemy receiving his boon. Justin approaches councilman Templeton to participate in his Sermon on the Mount for a New America. The Crowes hire a new maid – Sofie.

9. Lincoln Highway

Although the carnival has safely crossed the border to Wyoming, Jonesy and Libby are kidnapped by a group of men out to avenge the Ferris wheel death of the wife. They tar and feather Jonesy, and leave him and Libby in the desert. The next morning, Ben locates Stroud and Scudder using astral projection and heads to Cheyenne. On the road, he encounters Libby waving for help. To save the life of Jonesy, Ben needs to use his healing powers; while doing so, he unintentionally mends Jonesy's bad knee. Ruthie's irritations grow after she wakes up and finds the words "Sofie is the Omega -L" on her mirror. Lila keeps close watch on her. Iris overhears Justin talking to stroke-afflicted Norman about his childhood nightmares: A carnival is approaching, hiding his enemy. After Eleanor confides to Iris that she saw the devil in Justin's eyes, Iris takes her to a lake and murders her. Iris arrives late for Templeton's declaration of Congress candidacy. Norman grabs a policeman's gun and shoots at Justin, but misses. Justin shocks the crowd with forgiveness, but Iris finds a new ally in her plot against Justin. Awards: Emmy nominations for "Outstanding Music Composition for a Series (Dramatic Underscore)" and "Outstanding Cinematography for a Single-Camera Series".

10. Cheyenne, WY

Jonesy and Ben leave Libby with the carnival and drive to the motel of Ben's vision, only to find that Stroud has already left with the abducted Scudder. Ben recognizes the preacher of his dreams (Justin) in a newspaper article, and pays the motel clerk to deliver the newspaper to Samson. Ben and Jonesy leave for New Canaan. Ruthie/Lodz pays Lila a midnight visit and tells her the circumstances surrounding the death of Lodz. Libby tries to explain to her mother the story of Jonesy's healing, but Rita Sue is dismissive. Samson tells the carnies to pack up. Stroud delivers Scudder to Justin, but Wilfred Talbot Smith intervenes before Justin kills Scudder, explaining that the drugged Scudder's mind must be clear to pass on the boon. Stroud increases security with his armed Knights of Jericho. Iris recognizes her niece in Sofie. To disrupt the emerging alliance of Iris and Norman, Justin assigns Norman's caretaking to Sofie. Scudder breaks his bondage, murders Smith, and escapes in Stroud's car. However, Justin who was hiding in the back seat, emerges and decapitates Scudder.

11. Outside New Canaan

Despite the risk of detection, Ben does not want to miss a chance to kill his enemy and so remains at New Canaan while Jonesy returns to the carnival for assistance. Lila instigates a mutiny over Samson and a seemingly nonexistent Management. However, when Jonesy shows his healed knee, he gains the carnies' support for Ben's mission, and the caravan leaves for an arranged setup in New Canaan. Iris encounters Ben in Justin's bedroom armed with an axe. She convinces Ben to surrender the axe, and directs him to a baptism taking place at the lake. During the baptism ceremony, the body of the murdered Eleanor floats by. Ben spots Sofie and tries to warn her of Justin's evil nature, but she refuses to believe him. However, when she overhears the Crowes conversing in Russian and discovers Ben's broken mask in a drawer, she becomes suspicious. Justin attempts to seduce her during a thunderstorm, but Sofie rejects his advances. Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Hairstyling for a Series". Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".

12. New Canaan, CA

After hearing how Ben's powers work, Samson devises a grand plan. Libby and Jonesy have an open talk about his feelings for Sofie, and Iris confesses her sins to Norman. Meanwhile, Stroud locks Sofie in an abandoned barn after she saw Justin's tattooed chest and insulted him. Sofie experiences a series of visions of her carny past, of Justin, the Tattooed Man, Lodz's words to her mother, and finally of herself with Justin's black eyes saying, "this is your House." Jonesy, Ben and Samson hope to abduct Sofie from Justin's property, but when Samson and his carnies arrive to receive Iris's honorarium, they encounter Justin and Stroud. As Samson denies knowing a "Sofie", Stroud informs Justin of the obvious setup. Supported by many carnies, Ben's and Brother Justin's first and the series' final battle takes place on and near the carnival grounds. As Justin and Iris mount the Ferris wheel for a long ride, Ben begins to perform a mass-healing act as Benjamin St. John. After crumbling in pain and ripping his shirt open for everyone to see, Justin stops the Ferris wheel and enters Ben's tent. He pulls out the sickle that already killed Scudder, lacerates several devotees and Norman standing in his way, and pursues Ben into a cornfield. Justin cuts Ben on the arm and abdomen, and Ben's blade breaks apart. With Justin towering over him ready to carry out his last task, Ben remembers Management's words, grabs his broken blade and plunges it deep into Justin's tattooed chest where the branches meet. Meanwhile, Jonesy has tracked Stroud to Sofie's place, overpowers him and releases her, but Sofie shoots Jonesy down. The next morning, the carnies find Brother Justin with Emma's blade in his chest and bring Ben, still breathing, back to their camp. Stumpy and Rita Sue, whose outstanding debts are now covered by Iris's honorarium, reassure Libby that Jonesy will soon return. In the meantime, Sofie approaches Justin and places her hands on his chest. As Iris sees the corn die around them, the carnival leaves New Canaan with Ben's unconscious body bouncing in Management's bed... ( see also Characters of Carnivàle: Season 2 finale and character fates ).